Battlestar Galactica Fans Are Still Upset
Commentary by T.Shawn Hardy
To say that the road to a Battlestar Galactica revival has been very rocky, is underestimating it, to say the least. It has been full of so many ups and downs, twists and turns, that the frustration is now at an all-time high. Especialy for a fan base that are still so unbelievably vocal for a 24 year old show that only lasted one season! (Not counting the cheap, six episode imitation, Galactica: 1980.)
Amongst the high points of the Revival was Battlestar Galactica series star Richard (Apollo) Hatch listening to the fans by writing four books to continue the story (with the fifth due in 2003) and even mortgaging his own home to produce a 4 ½ minute trailer for both the fans and showing The Powers That Be what the fans wanted. (And fans applauded the efforts!) He even secured a large backing of funds for a movie or series…ALL of this because he believes in the show, just as the fans do.
When Bryan Singer and Tom Desanto (of the X-MEN and X2 movie fame) jumped into the game with their own production, the fans were a little reluctant. We weren’t sure of their intentions. Up to that point, fans were hoping for Richard’s efforts to evolve into a movie or series. But as their plans emerged, even Richard himself got behind their efforts, as did many fans.
Unfortunately, Bryan Singer focused 100% on X2 and Tom DeSanto had the rug pulled from beneath him in April 2002 when the SCI-FI Channel seized the project. (DeSanto was said to be three weeks from production!) Star Trek/Roswell’s Ronald D. Moore was brought aboard to “remake/reimagine” the original series. While the man is a talented writer/producer, fans were slapped in their collective faces by this.
Since the announcement, Moore has found little Internet support for his planned Battlestar Galactica mini-series… and most fans have been outright rejecting his plans. Yes, he has spoken to fans first-hand, answering a Q&A session on BattlestarGalactica.com. We appreciate and respect that, but the bottom line is: Fans keep speaking up for what they want… and it isn’t Moore’s remake concept. Just look around the Internet, or ask Battlestar Galactica fandom. People want a continuation with members of the original cast (characters), themes, ships and concepts, plus the addition of new actors/characters, technologies and story elements.
(Again: Richard Hatch’s “The Second Coming” trailer demonstrated the potential, as does his book series. And Internet web sites worldwide are supportive of a continuation, not a remake. That includes a petition supporting Tom DeSanto which has OVER 16,000 signatures!)
Ronald D. Moore has said many times that he has to follow what he believes to be right… and that is why he is doing a remake. This has left a very bitter taste in the mouths of us fans. Business-wise, he is ignoring what the fanbase (and potential viewers) want… and have clamored for in recent years. This is disappointing, given license holder Vivendi Universal’s financial situation… and need for a strong franchise opportunity, ie. Battlestar Galactica.
It has been many months now since we have heard from Ronald D. Moore. Many of us pray the entire re-imagining/remake idea is gone.
We are announcing our writing campaign to Mr. Barry Diller, head of Vivendi Universal/Universal Television. This letter writing campaign will take place on November 22, 2002. It will reconfirm that we fans are still here, still upset about a “remake” idea, and still wanting a continuation of the ORIGINAL Battlestar Galactica series.
I thank you very much for your time.